1. Home
  2. Extended Auto Warranty

Find the Best Extended Auto Warranty Companies in Buffalo, NY

Your vehicle is an investment. One way to protect it is with an extended auto warranty, or service protection plan, from an aftermarket company. This comes in handy after the manufacturer’s warranty ends. To help you understand coverage and learn how to select a policy, we researched the best extended auto warranty in Buffalo.

Take a Quiz

Get matched with an Accredited Partner

Compare Top Extended Auto Warranties

Overall satisfaction rating
  • 24 hour roadside assistance
  • 4 plans available
  • Direct warranty provider
  • Available in Buffalo

Coverage when you need it!

Learn More (855) 329-7711 Read More
Overall satisfaction rating
  • Free quote online
  • Rental car coverage
  • 24/7 roadside assistance
  • Available in Buffalo

Select 3 plan options with deductibles as low as $100. Covers vehicles for up to 5 years or 125,000 miles.

Learn More (866) 254-0172 Read More
Overall satisfaction rating
  • Available in Buffalo
  • Powertrain & specialty plans
  • Coverage for recreational vehicles
  • Plans for every vehicle & budget

Flexible payment plans, coverage on pricey items like transmissions and 24-hour roadside assistance are just a few of the features offered in CarShield’s customizable plans.

Learn More (800) 974-9385 Read More
Accredited Partner
Infinite Auto
Overall satisfaction rating
  • A+ BBB Rating
  • 24/7 roadside assistance
  • Guarantees 100% payment in event of any breakdown
  • Available in Buffalo

A+ Rated with the BBB. Infinite Auto Protection provides coverage for your vehicle in the event of any breakdown and guarantees 100% payment, less any deductibles, of all covered repairs.

Learn More (734) 366-4354 Read More
Accredited Partner
Protect My Car
Overall satisfaction rating
  • 3 plans available
  • 30-day money-back guarantee
  • Available in Buffalo
  • Rental car benefits

Protect My Car allows a long 60-month repayment plan. Although their Ambassador plan only offers partial coverage, Protect My Car’s other plans satisfy a wide array of needs.

Learn More (609) 401-2762
American Auto Shield
Overall satisfaction rating
  • Available in Buffalo
  • Serving customers for over a decade
  • Resolves claims quickly
  • Your choice of mechanic
Serves residents in
Buffalo, NY
(800) 531-1925
AA Auto Protection
  • Full coverage available
  • 5 plans available
  • 30-day money-back guarantee
  • Available in Buffalo
Serves residents in
Buffalo, NY
(888) 222-4445
Delta Auto Protect
Overall satisfaction rating
  • ASE-licensed technicians on staff
  • Available in Buffalo
  • Customizable plans
  • Price match promise
Serves residents in
Buffalo, NY
(866) 598-5429

How to choose an extended auto warranty in Buffalo

Buffalo Skyline

When you purchase an extended auto warranty, both your car and pocketbook will stay in better shape over the long run. In Buffalo, severe winter weather and potholed roads can damage the parts and systems in your car. An extended warranty may pay for repairs and replacement costs.

An extended auto warranty is likely beneficial to you if any of the following is true:

  • You drive fairly often.
  • You plan to keep the car after the original manufacturer’s warranty ends.
  • You drive on roads that are not well-maintained.
  • You don’t want to pay for unexpected repairs.
  • You care about increasing the resale value of your car.

Note that extended auto warranties are not the same as an original manufacturer’s warranty, which often expires before many vehicles require repairs. Though a dealer may offer an extended auto warranty during a vehicle purchase, there are advantages to buying from a third party. Often there are fewer servicing limitations, and the cost is less.

Extended auto warranties in Buffalo can be purchased for both new and used cars, and can cover different car parts such as the engine, transmission, cooling system, electrical system and brake system. Coverage can also include roadside services, towing, rental cars and more. Companies offer these services to different degrees.

The deductible for an extended auto warranty usually is $100 or less, in most cases. Ask how much the deductible is and when it’s applied.

When choosing an extended auto warranty in Buffalo, consider how long you want the coverage period to last based on how long you plan to keep the vehicle. Warranties begin after a short waiting period. Determine when you are and aren’t covered and where you will be allowed to get service. Confirm that you can transfer the warranty to a new owner if you choose to sell the car. Finally, make sure customers have reviewed the company positively and recommend it.

Extended Auto Warranty Reviews


Most plans sold by Endurance are directly administered, and each comes with 24-hour roadside assistance, rental car benefits and a 30-day money-back guarantee. Plans are 100% insured and will cover vehicles with up to 150,000 miles and 10 model years old. Buffalo customers believe Endurance offers reasonably priced warranties and has helpful representatives.

Endurance Learn More (855) 329-7711


Extended vehicle protection plans from CARCHEX come in five tiers and include 24/7 roadside assistance, towing, rental cars, gas delivery, trip interruption service and more. Each policy is insured by highly rated carriers. Customers can get repairs done at any licensed facility in the U.S. Customers, including in Buffalo, say it is easy to purchase from CARCHEX and rate the value highly.

CARCHEX Learn More (866) 254-0172


CarShield stands out for providing flexible mechanic choices, courtesy towing, flexible payment plans, 24/7 roadside assistance and rental car services. Getting coverage is as easy as requesting a free quote, personalizing your inclusions and picking the right plan.

CarShield Learn More (800) 974-9385

Infinite Auto

Infinite Auto Protection offers three extended auto warranty plans. Each comes with a 30-day money-back guarantee and 24/7 roadside assistance. Customers like being able to take their vehicles to any dealership or certified repair shop and say Infinite Auto Protection has an efficient claims process and low deductible.

Infinite Auto Learn More (734) 366-4354